question
Two of Anthony ,Bernard ,and Charles are fighting each other.
1. The shorter of Anthony and Bernard is the older of the two fighters.
2.The younger of Bernard and Charles is the shorter of the two fighter.
3.The taller of Anthony and Charles is the younger of the two fighters.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Answer:
From case 1: Suppose we consider Bernard as shorter then Anthony.
This implies that
1. Bernard is one of the fighter .
2. Bernard is older then the other fighter .
3.Anthony is taller then Bernard.
Now this implies that Bernard is one of the fighter:
from case 2:-Since Bernard is older then other fighter so to make case 2 true Charles will be one of the two fighter.And he will be younger Then Bernard.
This implies that Charles is other fighter.
This implies that
1.Charles is other fighter
2.Charles is younger then Bernard.
3.Charles is shorter then Bernard.
from case 3:The taller of Anthony and Charles is the younger of the two fighters.
Since from case 1 and 2 assumption we concluded that Bernard and Charles are fighter
so Charles will be taller then Anthony.
But since Anthony is taller then Bernard
Charles is shorter then Bernard. this can not be possible .
so out first consideration was wrong.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Now lets consider in other way
taking case 1: The shorter of Anthony and Bernard is the older of the two fighters.
Anthony will be shorter then Bernard
Anthony will be older then other fighter.
.Anthony is one of the two fighter
case 2: The younger of Bernard and Charles is the shorter of the two fighter.
Hear we consider Charles as fighter .
Charles is younger then Bernard
Charles is shorter then Anthony.
Bernard is older then charles.
case3:The taller of Anthony and Charles is the younger of the two fighters.
This implies Chales is taller then anthony .
so our case 2 consideration will be wrong
so Bernard will be another fighter
Final conclusion
So Anthony is Taller then Bernard
Bernard is oldre then anthony
Charles is not fighting
Bernard is shorter then everybody
Charles is not fighting
Two of Anthony ,Bernard ,and Charles are fighting each other.
1. The shorter of Anthony and Bernard is the older of the two fighters.
2.The younger of Bernard and Charles is the shorter of the two fighter.
3.The taller of Anthony and Charles is the younger of the two fighters.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Answer:
From case 1: Suppose we consider Bernard as shorter then Anthony.
This implies that
1. Bernard is one of the fighter .
2. Bernard is older then the other fighter .
3.Anthony is taller then Bernard.
Now this implies that Bernard is one of the fighter:
from case 2:-Since Bernard is older then other fighter so to make case 2 true Charles will be one of the two fighter.And he will be younger Then Bernard.
This implies that Charles is other fighter.
This implies that
1.Charles is other fighter
2.Charles is younger then Bernard.
3.Charles is shorter then Bernard.
from case 3:The taller of Anthony and Charles is the younger of the two fighters.
Since from case 1 and 2 assumption we concluded that Bernard and Charles are fighter
so Charles will be taller then Anthony.
But since Anthony is taller then Bernard
Charles is shorter then Bernard. this can not be possible .
so out first consideration was wrong.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Now lets consider in other way
taking case 1: The shorter of Anthony and Bernard is the older of the two fighters.
Anthony will be shorter then Bernard
Anthony will be older then other fighter.
.Anthony is one of the two fighter
case 2: The younger of Bernard and Charles is the shorter of the two fighter.
Hear we consider Charles as fighter .
Charles is younger then Bernard
Charles is shorter then Anthony.
Bernard is older then charles.
case3:The taller of Anthony and Charles is the younger of the two fighters.
This implies Chales is taller then anthony .
so our case 2 consideration will be wrong
so Bernard will be another fighter
Final conclusion
So Anthony is Taller then Bernard
Bernard is oldre then anthony
Charles is not fighting
Bernard is shorter then everybody
Charles is not fighting